SIG Knew About the P320 Failed Drop Safety Tests Months Before They Acknowledged It

That's right, SIG knew the P320 failed drop safety tests and kept quiet. Omaha Outdoors' intrepid Andrew Tuohey -- the man who discovered the drop-safety problem with the SIG SAUER P320 -- has been digging into obscure Pentagon reports. And he's found an interesting tidbit about the timing of what SIG knew and when they knew it regarding the Army's XM17 (P320) drop safety testing.

Omaha Outdoors testing regarding the P320 drop fire issue was conducted in early August 2017 and released on August 7, 2017. On August 4, 2017, SIG had stated that the company “has full confidence in the reliability, durability, and safety of its striker-fired handgun platform” and that there had been “zero (0) reported drop-related P320 incidents in the U.S. commercial market” as well as describing that “the P320 meets and exceeds all U.S. standards for safety.”

But as the highlighted portion of the Annual Report indicates, the Army had found the problem four months earlier.

The DOT&E Annual Report’s apparent statement that, sometime prior to April 2017, the Army directed the ECP as a result of failures during drop fire testing, which resulted in the lightweight components being adopted, is incongruent with previously public descriptions of the same events. As described on Soldier Systems in August 2017, “While the MHS passed DoD’s TOP 3-2-045 test with the trigger currently in the commercial P320, SIG proposed an enhanced trigger via Engineering Change Request E0005.” It is, of course, possible that both parties simultaneously discovered the drop fire issue and further simultaneously and separately directed (on the part of the Army) and requested (on the part of SIG) the ECP to address drop fire test failures. However, it does not explain the DOT&E description of the drop fire issue as apparently being known sometime before April 2017.

So SIG was extremely careful to note in their original statement to Omaha Outdoors that there hadn't been any incidents in the civilian market. That was an artfully worded, Clintonian denial of a problem they'd long been aware of. Read the whole thing.

Dan Zimmerman

Born and raised in St. Louis, Dan is now a happy Texan, living in the Live Music Capital of the World. He’s been shooting guns for the last 25 years and writing about them for the last eight or so. While he finds pistols and rifles lots o’ fun, it’s shotguns that have always really floated his boat. He’s happiest breaking clays but has become a fan of duck and pheasant hunting, too.

View Comments

  • it's pretty clear from the fast tracked adoption and the names around it what happened, somebody came out ahead financially in this

  • For me the whole Sig P320 experience has been full of lies from the promise of 299 exchange kits (that no one ever had any available and ended up being over 400 dollars) to the drop test. Most disappointing gun purchase ever. Wished I would have waited before I bought this gun but believed all the hype and bought one of the first ones.

  • As did "Honor" Guard which is a copy of the Sig P320 mechanically,,,I will stay with my Glocks and SIG P250s...

Published by
Dan Zimmerman

Recent Posts

What's In My Every Day Carry (EDC) Bag? [2023]

After my EDC update for the Spring and Summer season, I had readers ask about…

3 days ago

Harry's Holsters Icon 2.0 Holster Review

I'm no stranger to Harry's Holsters. Back in 2019 I reviewed the first version of…

5 days ago

Grey Ghost Gear Lightweight Assault Pack Mod 1 Review [2023]

Keeping in line with our "Spring-EDCleaning", I wanted to give a review of the bag…

1 week ago

Optics Versus Irons on Pistols [2023]

Over the past few years the debate between irons versus optics on pistols has raged…

2 weeks ago

Cognitive Conclave After Action Report [2023]

There is a line I attribute to Claude Werner that goes something to the effect…

2 weeks ago

Mystery Ranch Zoid Bag Review - Organizer Deluxe [2023]

Over the last few years, I've realized that I like my gear organized. Not just…

3 weeks ago